Bias in content recommendation and moderation

Digital Methods Winter School and Data Sprint 2021


Digital Methods Winter School and Data Sprint 2021

4-8 January 2021

Owing to COVID-19, all of the Winter School is likely to be held online. If in the unlikely event it is a hybrid event, here is the location information.

Opening Day Location and Time:
Oudemanhuispoort 4-6 (Law Faculty Building, University of Amsterdam)
1012 CN Amsterdam
Room: D0.09
9.15am Please be on time!

Everyday location:
Digital Methods Initiative
University of Amsterdam
Turfdraagsterpad 9
1012 XT Amsterdam

Digital Methods Winter School and Data Sprint

The Digital Methods Initiative (DMI), Amsterdam, is holding its annual Winter School on 'Bias in content recommendation and moderation'. The format is that of a (social media and web) data sprint, with tutorials as well as hands-on work for telling stories with data. There is also a programme of keynote speakers. It is intended for advanced Master's students, PhD candidates and motivated scholars who would like to work on (and complete) a digital methods project in an intensive workshop setting. For a preview of what the event is like, you can view short video clips from previous editions of the School.

When one argues that algorithms are biased, how is the case made? Similarly, when it is claimed that content moderation (that results in removal or demonetisation) is unfair, what is considered to be a convincing account? This year’s Digital Methods Winter School is dedicated to the empirical study of the bias in algorithmic output and moderated content. We would like to take stock of the claims made about biases (in search engines as well as social media platforms), and pay special attention to the measurement and representation of these biases. First, we would like to present the celebrated cases (such as discriminatory pricing, stereotyping and computer vision training), but also a discussion of the supposed political motivations surrounding takedowns by Google, Facebook, Twitter and others. Subsequently, we would like to critique and learn from how bias is represented and also put forward methods that capture and seek to lay bare bias, such as algorithmic auditing and other testing regimes. Finally, we would like to visualise these biases in ways that make them more legible and apparent.

At the Winter School there are the usual social media tool tutorials (and the occasional tool requiem), but also continued attention to thinking through and proposing how to work with social media data after the demise of the API.

[Some of these resources are still being prepared!]

  1. Call for participation and general information:
  2. Welcome Package: Contents: Welcome note, day-to-day schedule, maps of venue locations, coffee, and lunch places, preparations, and further instructions.
  3. The welcome package folder: Contents: the reader, face book, and other linked documents.
  4. Map of Coffee and Lunch places:
  5. Project descriptions to be pitched on the opening day:
  6. The reader: And the reader folder:
  7. Tutorials:
  8. Form to sign up for tutorials:
  9. Map of principal locations:
  10. G-doc template for project reports: And Wiki template:
  11. Collaborative note taking for Keynotes:
  12. The Face Book of international participants:
  13. Official hashtag: #dmi21
  14. Slack Channel: Link to join:
  15. Presentation slides:

Applications: Key Dates

The deadline for application is 16 November 2021. To apply please send a letter of motivation, your CV, a headshot photo, 100-word bio as well as a copy of your passport (details page only) to winterschool [at] Notifications of acceptance will be sent on 17 November. The full program and schedule of the Winter School are available by 16 December 2021.

Tuition Fees, Accommodations & Completion Certificates

The fee for the Digital Methods Winter School 2021 is EUR 695, and upon completion all participants receive certificates (and 6 ECTS). To complete the Winter School successfully all participants must co-present the final presentation and co-author the final project report, evidenced by the presentation slides as well as the final report itself. Payment information is sent along with the notification on 17 November 2021. Students at the University of Amsterdam do not pay fees. The Winter School is self-catered. The venue is in the center of Amsterdam with abundant coffee houses and lunch places. Participants are expected to find their own housing (short-stay sites are helpful), or we have available accommodations at the Student Hotel:

The Student Hotel Amsterdam
Jan van Galenstraat 335
1061 AZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Tel: +31 20 760 4000
(Arrival: 3 January 2021; Departure: 9 January 2021)
reservations [at] or tel. +31 20 760 7575. See full booking instructions including discount code.

If you would like to have accommodations at the Student Hotel, please write to the student hotel directly. To avoid disappointment, please write to them as early as possible. Ask the hotel for the 15% Digital Methods Winter School discount.

For further questions, please contact the local organizers, at winterschool [at]

Please bring your laptop computer, your European plug as well as the VGA/HDMI adaptor for connecting to the projector.

About DMI

The Digital Methods Winter School is part of the Digital Methods Initiative (DMI), Amsterdam, dedicated to developing techniques for Internet-related research and to the study of the natively digital. The Digital Methods Initiative holds the annual Digital Methods Summer Schools (fourteen to date), which are intensive and full-time undertakings in the Summertime.

There is a practical textbook, Doing Digital Methods (Sage, 2019). The Digital Methods book (MIT Press, 2015) provides the methodological outlook that frames and informs the work of the DMI. It is accompanied by a companion volume about mapping social and political issues with digital methods: Issue Mapping for an Ageing Europe (Amsterdam University Press, 2015), which is also freely available on the web as an open access monograph. Further information and resources about digital methods can be found at - including links to example projects, publications, tools, an introductory "founding narrative" about the Digital Methods Initiative as well as short bios of the affiliated researchers.

The coordinators of the Digital Methods Initiative are Dr. Sabine Niederer (Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences) and Dr. Esther Weltevrede (New Media & Digital Culture, University of Amsterdam), and the director is Richard Rogers, Professor of New Media & Digital Culture, University of Amsterdam.

About Digital Methods as a Concept

Digital methods is a term coined as a counterpoint to virtual methods, which typically digitize existing methods and port them onto the Web. Digital methods, contrariwise, seek to learn from the methods built into the dominant devices online, and repurpose them for social and cultural research. That is, the challenge is to study both the info-web as well as the social web with the tools that organize them. There is a general protocol to digital methods. At the outset stock is taken of the natively digital objects that are available (links, tags, threads, etc.) and how devices such as search engines make use of them. Can the device techniques be repurposed, for example by remixing the digital objects they take as inputs? Once findings are made with online data, where to ground them? Is the baseline still the offline, or are findings to be grounded in more online data? See R. Rogers (2009), The End of the Virtual: Digital Methods. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.


We are using the #DMI21 hashtag as the backchannel for communication (to use a throwback term for Twitter usage). Some pictures from a past Winter School. Here is the Facebook Group from one year, and from a recent Summer School. Here are pictures from a variety of DMI Summer and Winter School Flickr streams.
Topic attachments
I Attachment Action Size Date Who Comment
767046-large.pngpng 767046-large.png manage 59 K 30 Sep 2020 - 04:54 SvrTech I am reading your post from the beginning, it was so interesting to read & I feel thanks to you for posting such a good blog, keep updates regularly.I want to share about Mulesoft training .
dmi_winter1.jpgjpg dmi_winter1.jpg manage 30 K 14 Sep 2020 - 10:56 RichardRogers  
dmi_winter2.jpgjpg dmi_winter2.jpg manage 18 K 14 Sep 2020 - 10:56 RichardRogers  
dmi_winter3.jpgjpg dmi_winter3.jpg manage 25 K 14 Sep 2020 - 10:57 RichardRogers  
dmi_winter4.jpgjpg dmi_winter4.jpg manage 19 K 14 Sep 2020 - 10:57 RichardRogers  
Topic revision: r12 - 01 Dec 2020, GuillenTorres
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding Foswiki? Send feedback